Smart Pots High Caliper Smart Pot Tray Liner 4ftx4ftx12in, Black (100047429)

Quality stitching, is correctly sized, not much to say other than it is and does what it's designed for.

Needs to be stapled into the beds because the sides will fall down making it clumsy to fill the beds. Otherwise a great product and working very well in my garden bed! I'm still waiting for the second one I ordered to start another garden bed!

Loved it! Well built and is made of thicker material than the ones in the store.

I was very disappointed in this product. I realize the name states it is a tray liner but I saw a response in the questions asked that it works very well as a planting bed on it's own. I can tell you that is not true. This is a liner and requires a support structure surround all sides. When I put soil in it the sides collapsed outward. It is folded and in the garage.

See how well these do in a 4 x 4 area , thinking that they will do well

I have been using one of these and three round ones for three years and it is almost like new today. Water drains well. My only complaint is that the sides fall out unless framed. I used 8" X 16" cinder blocks. The round ones are totally self supporting.