Belle Beautyby Kim Gravel Waterproof Gel Lip Liner - Cruelty Free Waterproof Lip Liner Pencil - Anti Feathering Moisturizing Formula (Mauve Nude)

I bought these after reading on EWG site that they are a clean beauty item with low risk toxicity of a 1.Hats off to Kim for making toxic free!!....I got 2 mauve nude and pink nude...The mauve nude is just what i was looking for with more pink than brown!Beautiful color!Dont like the pink nude as its orangy on me.The staying power is good on my lips.

It's a good base color for me. I use a lip line disguising cocoa butter lip base beforehand. Unfortunately whether I prime it with the lip base first or not, the pencil line needs frequent retouching, even with spray-on make-up fixative. It's disappointing that this doesn't stay put even without eating or drinking. I guess it may be a lot of ask for, and perhaps too much. But that is what I was expecting, so I have to only give this three stars.

Does not stay on very long.

Really love this liner. It's very light feeling and doesn't dry out my lips like all the others. Definitely will be back for more 👍

Does exactly what it said, keeps the lip color, lipstick, from running.

I really like this lip liner. It’s the only one I’ve ever used that doesn’t make my lips crack, chap or get irritated. It applies smoothly and lasts a good amount of time. The color match for the pink nude is perfect to my natural lip color too. It’s also lasted a surprisingly long time.. used nearly everyday for 4-5 months now!

Cosmetics should not be without the wrapper or a seal. This is a nice pencil, but I'm disappointed that there was no protective seal or package.

I have been using Belle Beauty lipliners for 4 years and haven't found any other prestige brand that can match its staying power. The formula is most yet has extreme, rich pigment to keep it on your lips for hours. I love all the colors and will continue purchasing these over another brands.