Essential Eye Pencil | Organic Eyeliner Pencil | Castor Oil Infused | Long-Lasting COSMOS Pigments | Vegan, Cruelty-free, Gluten-free | Unique Soft-Tip Formulation for Easy Application

I really like this eyeliner. I went from a liquid eyeliner filled with chemicals to this one. It doesn’t stay on long as my liquid, but that’s comparing apples and oranges. Easy to remove. Not hard like some pencils. Color is perfect too. I’m very happy and will purchase again.

The eyeliner is a favorite in my home. it is creamy and stays on, dark and is th eonly eyeliner to not cause me and my mother any irritation. Usually our eyes water, but with this pencil it does not. HOWEVER, it is a difficult pencil to sharpen! A lot of the pencil is wasted when I try to sharpen it. it falls apart easily and never reaches a fine point. Wonderful product but it will be spent quickly.

I don't know how to rate this eyeliner pencil. When I first got it I really really liked it. Best I had ever had. I bought the right color. Then it came time to twist it up but nothing happened. For a few weeks I kept twisting everything again and again. Then I thought this is really a rip off because all you get is just the original amount you see when you first get it. Today I started reading other reviews. And I see that there are some similar but different Twist problems. So obviously I got a defective pencil. I live outside of the US and mailing products back to a company is not an easy thing. So would I buy this again? I am not sure.

Gave one star bc at least the small amount I could use of the coco was great, but that's not enough. Cannot get the product to twist or pump or however one is supposed to get more product out and if you look a little farther in the Q's you'll see I'm not the only one having difficulty getting the product to twist or pump more out, etc. Au Naturale if some of us are just clueless, post a video to show us how to use your product bc I bought 2 of these eyeliners and just broke the end off of one in frustration...FYI there is product at the other end of the pencil--just not sure how to get it out the correct end! P.S. the one I broke was the one in black that would not distribute color the way the "coco" one does... something is wrong w formula and design. I soooo overpaid! Disappointed, wish I could return, but it's too late.

I do like it because I'm allergic to coconut oil and this doesn't appear to have any in it. But I can't figure out how to sharpen it. It is dull and does pull on your skin.

I like this eyeliner. It goes on quite smoothly, which was a pleasant surprise. My eyes have become extremely sensitive and many "regular" eyeliners give me red, itchy eyes. This one does not, which was my main consideration. In addition, as a pregnant and breastfeeding mom, I really like knowing there are no harmful chemicals in this that could effect me or either of my little ones. As a pregnant mom of a 13 month old, I have limited time for things like makeup, and I find I really need to confidence boost that a swipe of eyeliner gives. Over the past 8 months (since my eye sensitivity began) I've tried many different eyeliners, most which I could not use, and many that didn't work as nicely as this one. It's been a long search for an eyeliner that both works well and doesn't hurt my eyes, but I think I'll probably stick with this one now.That being said, there are a couple negatives to this pencil. The first is that it needs to be sharpened fairly frequently. This is a pain, and just one more step in my already rushed routine. The second is that it does smudge a bit once applied. If applied lightly, it ends up sort of disappearing over a few hours. However, if applied more heavily, you run the risk of raccoon eyes. It's not the the most smudgy eyeliner I've ever used, but it is a nuisance, and requires tidying and re-applying throughout the day. However, as its non-toxic and non-irritating, I'll probably stick with it.

So far so good. I love the natural ingredients. I only barely use it on my waterline to make it seem like I'm not wearing eyeliner, so I can't really say much about the quality, lines, etc. It does go onto my eyelash line pretty easily. Of course It's not as dark and noticeable as the wet eye marker I was using before, which is a good thing in my case. It doesn't irritate my eyes or go on my eyeballs whatsoever. Also I don't get dark circles when I rub my eyes or wash my face like my previous eyeliner.

The Au Naturale products are amazing! I love that this brand is non toxic and everything they have is soft, feels good on my ultra sensitive skin and blends really well. This pencil is black and can be used thin or thick or even smudge for a softer look. Worth every penny and lasts a long long time!