CLIO PROFESSIONALWaterproof Pen Liner 0.01 fl.oz 02 Brown

I follow a Korean skin care routine and heavily moisturize my skin twice a day. I tried this eyeliner after reading great reviews stating that this eyeliner is smudge-proof and would last throughout the day. Unfortunately it did not do either. It smudged with the slightest touch and generally did not last for more than a few hours. It is also supposed to be waterproof, but when my eyes watered it would immediately come off no matter how careful I was when I dabbed my eyes dry. I recommend Stilia Stay All Day Waterproof Liquid Eye Liner. True to it's name it does not smudge and will remain on until you wash it off. It also comes in many different colors.

Smudge proof and longevity is a definite. Easy to apply. Love the brown. Definitely getting it in black.

I like this, it's easy to use and strongly pigmented. FYI for those looking for a super fine line - this is a marker tip. It's a small marker, but a marker nonetheless, so keep that in mind when buying/applying.

I liked it, however, I could not use it a lot. It dried up faster than other products that I have used. However, it does have a great wing.

I have sensitive eyes but i had no reaction to this eyeliner. It’s also really smudge proof!