StilaStay All Day Waterproof Liquid Eye Liner Dark Brown for Women 0.016 oz, 1 Count (Pack of 1)

I would give this no stars if I could. I was heavily nfluenced by positive reviews, but I can honestly say this is the absolute worst eye liner I have ever bought. It is easy to remove because it just slides off anyway and after a mere 2 hours or even less it is gone. I have never had to actually remove it. This eye liner is going in the bin tonight. It's a total rip off. There are far far far better brands and products around.,p. Buy this and you will not need to buy remover! Every cloud!

This stuff does last! I had to use a strong eye makeup remover to get it off, so in terms of longevity- full marks.I'm a bit dissapointed with how much I had to reapply this, it's not opaque and with every added layer you lose the definition you worked to create. I wasnt wearing a particularly difficult or chunky eyeshadow, just a good quality neutral set of colours, and it did not want to apply over that. Same with other brands so I know it's not the eyeshadow fault. Based on this and its price tag, I wouldnt buy this product again. I have other stila products and this one just doesnt hit the mark.

Been buying this for years, normally over the moon with it but this one doesn’t seem to be as good, it doesn’t dry very quickly and so it smudged a bit and it seemed to wear off really quickly, maybe just a bad batch, I will give it another chance but I am a little disappointed…..

Searching for a smudge proof long wearing eyeliner. My skin is a little on the oily side. This eyeliner smudges very badly. It does not even last half a day for me. I use the brown liner.

I had the black one and loved it so decided to get the brown one for a more discreet look but I don't actually think it's as good. It's not as easy to apply as the ink does not stay on the skin. Will go back to the black version.