VINGLI Pool Cover Reel Above Ground Swimming Pool Cover Reel 16 FT Without Decking Solar Blanket Roller Systems with Tube Set for Various Shape Pool

I am not sure why this has low rating compared to Intex...I started with the Intex reel and ended up with this one. They both serve the same function and here is the comparison on a 14' round pool. This is also considering the price, for the price between the options this is the better option. Its not a $300+ unit though.The biggest issue is the Intex pole goes into the reel, the Vigal goes over a nub on the reel. This is a two fold issue. If the Intex pole bends under stress, the force is applied to the reel and stops the reel from moving. I was unable to completely unroll my cover by pulling it from inside the pool. The Vigal doesnt have this issue since it goes on the outside of the reel, the force doesnt jam it up. Secondly, this allows you to replace the pole with a solid aluminum, pvs, or galvanized pipe for a more solid unit over all. You can just slide it over the nub and screw it in.The next biggest difference is the mounting options, I built a whole mounting bracket set up with pipes and posts so the system would be away from the pool. I couldnt get the Intex to really sit well, it wobbles etc. Just a hassle and looks bad. Vigal allows you to mount on a flat surface, on a bar surface, and actually switch in-between fairly easily.The cons are that it seems fragile, I havnt had any issues using it carefully though. The clip/rope system is better on the Intex on how it attaches to the reel pole. This was fixed with good quality double sided tape on the Vigal.I would have preferred longer mounting screws for the flat surface mount, which I switched out anyway.

Very cheaply made. It cannot handle the weight of a 16 foot wide by 32 feet long solar cover. Bends and bows badly. Also first day the cheap clamp downs snapped (broke) while realing cover in slowly. I will be modifying this one to work by running the largest size wooden dowel that fits in rod to prevent bowing. As for the broken clamps will most likely modify by bolting through the pool rail.Does not function easily without spending more money to modify.I would not recommend this one as a good buy or product

First, it fits perfectly to my above-ground pool. Length was just right and it was very easy to install.Second, it absolutely does the job, holding and bringing in the pool cover. In this way, its sturdy.Third, the side attachments are delicate. It's made primarily of plastic so it has already had pieces broken. The wind has knocked it off causing the plastic supports to break. I'm sure there are better and sturdier products out there. With that said, we've used it for 2 years, and despite being knocked off several times by wind and weather, it's still usable. If your looking for something quick and easy, just to get your pool set up, this is perfect. If your looking for longevity, you probably need to keep looking and spend the extra money.

Using for 12x24 above ground pool to hold solar cover. It doesn't clamp well without popping off. I used a couple long thick zip ties to help secure it to the frame and it is much better. Once you get the size figured out and screwed together, seems to work OK, just roll and unroll carefully.

This has been a lifesaver. I have a 14ft round above ground pool that i use an xtra large tarp over. I mounted this to posts and attached the tarp. It makes it sooo easy for my kids and myself to remove or replace tarp. I added wooden closet rods inside the metal rods for extra stability. It has held up to rain, snow and all sorts of weather and keeps leaves and debris outta the pool yesr round . I absolutely love this and once mine eventually wears out, i would def buy again.

This worked perfectly on my swim spa. It is 8x14 so no sag over that short distance like others reported. It is plastic and may not last years but I could have spent 4x as much for higher quality.

Working as it should this far

This roller is extremely flimsy and unable to handle the weight of the lightest covers. The bar in the middle bends a crazy amount under the weight and the roller mounts are about to snap. I regret this purchase but it’s too late to get a refund now