Bil-JacReal Chicken Soft Treats for Dogs 2 Flavor Variety Bundle Original Recipe Liver Treats Gooberliscious Peanut Butter Flavor Treats, 10 Ounces Each (1 Bag of Each)

We're on our second order so far. All have been fresh/soft. Not a strong scent so it isn't offensive to me but enough to peak the puppy's interest in the beginning. Didn't take her long to learn the word. Has helped with potty training. Personally can not arrest to flavor but pup likes them.

This review is about the Peanut butter treats only. The liver treats are perfect but the peanut butter ones were dry and easily crumbled, leaving very few whole treats in the bag. As small as they are to begin with, they really aren't useful as training treats.

My dog loves these snacks. They are much more nutritional than the cheap snacks. Bil Jac is the only snack for us. Always very fresh and he loves the peanut butter and the peanut butter and banana flavors.

Well I haven’t tasted them but my dogs seem to like them. I like the size. It’s a soft snack. I have an English bulldog and a rescue dog that I think is a min pin mix.

It's funny for me to give a 5-star review on Flavor because trust me I did not taste my dog's treats. However she appears to like them a lot :-) I have been looking for small easy treats for training and these peanut butter ones are perfect!

Great for problem solving toy. I put these in dog thinker treat...she has it figured out but like to bring me the toy to fill up several times on daily basis.

Obi has loved these since 15 wks when we got him... only treat he will eat and they do not give him an allergies

Im going by Titan's (my dog) always wanting more on the flavor one here. We use these daily for pills he needs to take. They are mostly soft so perfect to push pills into, but they are pretty small. He does lovvve the peanut butter ones. His fave by far!