stila Stay All Day Waterproof Liquid Eye Liner, Midnight (Deep Blue)

Best eye liner ever. i had bought stila in a sephora shop and ordered it online now. stays put throughout the day, doesnt smudge, very convenient to apply and comes off easy at the end of the day.

Eyeliner comes off too easily; not evenly.

This eye liner works well, but it didn't last very long, so I won't likely buy it again.

I kept on ordering this product because I loved the color (midnight blue) and the ease of use. Once on my eyelids it seems to stay in place fairly well, in spite of my oily skin. But, even when making certain the cap is firmly attached and the pen is stored in an upright position with the brush at the bottom -- the tube seems to dry out very fast (especially for the price)! I get about 15 normal uses out of it - with a thin and smooth line. Then I start fighting it every time I use it. I shake the tube like crazy, press the brush hard on my hand to try and start the pigment flowing, dot it on my lid and then try to join the dots together, and have even tried laying the brush sideways to get more color (forming a thick blotchy line). If I press it really hard against the lid I can sometimes get a fat choppy line -- but it's not the thin line like it was in the first few uses. Once I realized I was spending more than $1 per use, I realized I couldn't continue buying it. The sad part is that I haven't found any other waterproof pen eyeliner that's either navy/midnight blue or eggplant colored. Sigh...

Used to this brand was awesome and waterproof looked great but now for much cheaper the Chinese versions of water proof eyeliners are way better . I’m not sure what happened but the last three I’ve bought have dried out within a month of wearing about 3-4 x a week and that when it works

Who wants to be rained on when you attend a wedding at least I didn't have raccoon eyes in the wedding photos. Didn't expect to be part of the official wedding photos but I was and thankfully my Stila eyeliner remains clean and fresh. My cousin suggested this liner and I'm so glad she did. I'm in my 50's, and I hate makeup but I need all the help I can get.