Neil Gaiman's a Study in Emerald

The story is very short and the solution is discovered and explained so quickly that you can almost miss it. If the perpetrators have been allowed to escape in order to return in a sequel please don't bother Mr. Gaiman.An unsatisfying read that is not worth the money.

Excellent Holmesian-Lovecraftian concept and very well crafted and illustrated story. All-round terrific. However, it’s a too frustratingly brief glimpse into an absolutely fascinating world. Needed to be at least twice as long! It’s a compliment but please authors, don’t make this all we ever get of this world.

Disappointing ... son loves Sherlock so bought this upon recommendation from friend. Won’t spoil it but it’s not what we expected.

Good read but extremely short! Can't justify the price for what it is.

This could have been a great take on an age old story but all the areas where it could have been awesome it lacked, such a shame as this could have been the best take on SH since the recent movies