NykaaGlamoreyes Colour Eye Pencil Kajal smudge-proof, Water-proof & fade-proof formula, keeps the intense color locked down for long hours - Voodoo Grey 04 (1.2gm)

Good one ..not getting smudge..easy to use so far ...

I am typically a fan of felt tip eyeliners, but have been delving into gel potted eyeliners. Starting off with the positives, this gel is pretty decent. It comes with quite a bit of it and is a smooth consistency. It does dry pretty quick and is long-lasting. I find I do not have to "set" this one with eyeshadow like I do similar products, so that is a score. As for the negatives, the silicone brush is not helpful in application. I find it does not pick up much product, requiring you to re-dip the brush after every single tiny stroke. It also tends to drag my eyelid with it, no matter how light the touch. This results in a very unsmooth, messy eyeliner. The tip is also toooo flexible, which, again, makes it hard to achieve a solid line. I have not found more suitable brush for this, putting my use of the eyeliner itself on hold for now.

This gel is thick but the silicone "brush" picks up the gel fine. When applying it, it gets frustrating to work with. I can't do one full smooth line and have to continuously put more gel on the applicator to get the full line. I would prefer to do the line all in one go vs. segmented lines.The silicone brush is great in theory but it's too flexible for me. There were multiple times that the tip kicked out to the side of where I was trying to line and caused the eyeliner to go elsewhere on my lid.Once the eyeliner is on, it looks great and definitely holds. I did a test line on the back of my hand before trying it on my eyes and even with bathing and hand washing, while it's not as pigmented as when I first applied it, the line is still there (I have dry skin so that may make it last longer).I'm not overly impressed other than how long it lasts.

This was my first experience with an eyeliner that works like this. I'm happy to say it was a positive one! It's incredibly strong, and passed aggressive smudge tests on my skin as well as was very difficult to remove with just water. I will say it does take a couple reapplications to get the boldest line however.

I've used various gel eyeliners, and this is one of the worst. It's too thick and not very gel-like, making it difficult to apply smoothly. The silicone brush is a nice alternative to bristle brushes, but it's not very high quality. The product is also made in P.R.C., so if you're weary of makeup products made in China, it's probably best to avoid this.

This gel eyeliner is definitely as long lasting as it gets. It's nearly impossible to remove without a dedicated oil based eye makeup remover, but that's the sign of a good waterproof product.My biggest gripe is that the silicone brush that it comes with is utterly useless. I opted to use my own gel liner brush and I am much happier for it. The product is great, but the brush is not.