The Dream and Its Amplification [The Fisher King Review Volume 2]
S**L
In The Garden of the Dreaming Mind
"Amplification of Dreams" is not a light book, but one rich in its variety of earnest expression. These fourteen authors reach down into their depths to bring personal insights about the mind's (or psyche's), dream capacity -- or you may say, the amplification thereof. Every chapter is different, it's a book to keep nearby, pick up and read over parts again, as I have been doing, and enjoying it more as I do so. What stands out for me?To mention a few:Isler's Alpine Dreams making their way into the regions centuries old fairy tales, Wikman's own near death emxperience embodied as a dream, Swift-Furlotti's dream wherein an actual snake ritual and initiation, or new birth, takes place. Snakes, which are probably the oldest recognized key dream image around, come up again in Singer's heart touching story.Abramovitch 's attitudes on Jewish dream work from early Talmudic times, is similar to the 6th century Ancient Greeks, in the Temple of Asclepius, where seekers sought the priests' counsel in the dream abaton or temple.Shalit mentions the power of archetypal or dreams of the collective, like Jungs's rivers of blood dreams, 1913, just prior to of World War I.He dispenses a large amount of Jungian information here. If you're a thinking type you may respond one way, a feeling type, then you'll have another reaction.Gilda Franz writes with all her heart in 'Dreams and Sudden Death' and gives us some practical advice on how to delve into and amplifiy one's dream.Dream work is not new, Jung just expanded upon it greatly for our present era and in doing brought a whole new dimension to the science and art of psychology.These fourteen scholars manage to bring all of their wisdom and experience under one tent. I wish I had had this bok in psych grad school 18 years ago, although one does not need to be an academic to appreciate it's scope and depth.
A**N
a great read for the inexperienced in psychoanalytical lingo too!
This book is fabulous! It offers vivid portrayals of the dream life and how this world mirrors our conscious experience. In my experience books on dreams are either uber scientific and indecipherable to a person with little or no psychological education or they are completely unsophisticated. This book is perfect.
M**R
OK-ish
Havent read it all yet, but found the first 3 articles distinctly pedestrian. Good ideas but prosaically exprest.
D**R
Book Review by Robin B. Zeiger, Ph.D.
One of my earliest childhood memories is of a dream. As a psychologist, avid dreamer, and writer, I remain in awe of the power and depth of dream analysis. I invite my patients, supervisees, friends, and family to share dreams. And I welcome my dream world into my heart and soul. Again and again, dream work offers a window into the personal and collective soul. The Dream and Its Amplification by Erel Shalit and Nancy Swift Furlotti , Fisher King Press, 2013, is an excellent tribute to this deep soul-work from a Jungian perspective. Shalit and Furlotti present us with a series of essays by experts in the field. Yet, rather than reading a dry text filled with psychological jargon, we are treated to writings that are aesthetically pleasing. The chapters are short and appear deceptively simple. Yet, as I digested the book, I often felt as if I was reading good poetry. The words and images continue to resonate; beckoning us to travel deeper within.At times Jungian writers are accused of being too esoteric. The writing is filled with jargon and hard to digest concepts. In contrast, Shalit and Furlotti frame the book with an excellent introduction to dream analysis easily understandable and translatable to real life. We are offered a window into the world of dream amplification and active imagination. This is followed by fourteen chapters authored by a diversity of writers. The reader is introduced to symbols, archetypes, personal stories, diverse dreams, and poetry. There are also several inspiring illustrations. I am looking forward to referring patients and supervisees, as well as colleagues to this collection.One of my favorite images from the book comes from a chapter entitled The Dream as Gnostic Myth by Ronald Schenk Schenk reflects on the journey:For the gnostic, the present state is only a sojourn, and a journey of transformation is required. The journey is one of travail, involving a wandering through the unredeemed world, often imaged as following a meandering trail, gathering lost or forgotten “sparks” or aspects of the soul. The journey need not be one of space, but rather than of time, representing stages of transformation.I invite the professional and the lay-person alike to join the journey of dream amplification via this excellent collection of essays.Robin B. Zeiger received her Ph.D. in clinical psychology in 1985 from the University of Illinois of Chicago. She has practiced as a clinical psychologist and supervisor and is currently training as a Jungian analyst in Israel. Robin enjoys dialoguing and journeying with her dreams via art, writing, and sand-play.
S**A
One of the best dream Interpretation books
It provides concrete examples with a link to life events and decisions showing us how the unconscious not only shows us the conflicts but also supports our decision-making process. A fantastic book.
I**R
A disturbing trend revealed
I think the best way to look at this book is how Dr. Jung advised looking at the unconscious itself; that is, with eyes wide open to separate the wheat from the chaff.The fourteen essays are designed to illustrate how the use of parallels as found in mythology, folk tales and other art forms help to clarify the meaning of dreams.While the book's blurb correctly states that amplification "becomes particularly important when the image does not carry a personal meaning or significance and is not part of a person's everyday life", I don't believe that this point is emphasized enough throughout the book itself.Instead, especially with some of the contributors, there tends to be a slippage into a kind of grandiose view of amplification, treating it as if every dream has to be viewed through this potentially intoxicating prism. Following this procedure religiously can invite parody as was once devastatingly executed by James Hillman.Therefore in my view, some of the essays are written by analysts who have not adequately heeded Dr. Jung's warnings to avoid becoming "identified with the archetypes" with which they are dealing.The result in my opinion is sometimes a style of overblown language which could all too easily put off newcomers to the Jungian approach to the unconscious mind.Dr. Jung himself had the ability to combine a certain down-to-earth practical side while also getting across the very real transcendent aspects of the psyche.Similarly, the recent book by analyst Dr. Donald Kalsched, "Trauma and the Soul", is an excellent example where no slippage occurs regarding the usual Jungian standards and one is able to absorb both the practical side of therapy along with the great depths of the spiritual side of the psyche in an involving, vital way.Another example of what I feel is a certain careless approach to the maintaining of fundamental standards includes the fact that, while the Introduction expresses gratitude "to the eminent Jungian analysts" who contributed chapters to the book, most of the "Biographical Statements" lack the basic phrase which I have relied on over the years, namely, one that states accreditation by a recognized Jungian training institute, e.g. "A diplomate of the C.G. Jung Institute, Zurich", or of New York etc.While it's clear from some of the biographies lacking this statement that the person must have been accredited by a recognized Jungian training facility, with others it's not so obvious and perhaps even doubtful.Of course, very insightful ideas and views regarding the Jungian approach can be found among therapists and others who were not trained in an accredited Jungian institute, but I personally prefer to know the exact qualifications of someone who is presenting himself or herself as a "Jungian analyst" (eminent or not) in a publication that's apparently purporting to contain an official Jungian viewpoint.In addition, there are in my view some inaccurate definitions present which are beyond what one would consider just a bit of internal bickering.For example, the term "nigredo" is essentially defined in one of the essays as "black alchemy".In contrast, it is defined, for instance, by analyst Daryl Sharp in "Jung Lexicon":"An alchemical term, corresponding psychologically to the mental disorientation that typically arises in the process of assimilating unconscious contents, particularly aspects of the shadow."I think it's possible to see in the phrase "black alchemy" a certain leaning towards a "New Age" approach which in my view is not productive in our increasingly frenetic world which needs some solid, usable methods which can be adopted by the "average person".This touches on a main point that I wish to make as illustrated by the overall nature of this book.While in my estimation it does contain some very professional, readable and valuable essays, others display a generally poor quality and these often spiral off into a sort of airy elitism, containing in addition a fair amount of name-dropping of renowned figures in Jungian circles as if to boost the author's own shaky contribution.Unfortunately, such a trend is not new and could further damage the chance for the very useful and meaningful methods of Jungian psychology of reaching an ever growing audience which instead appears to be a shrinking one.For example, I live in a metropolitan area of over three and a half million people. In the 1980's and 1990's, the local Jung Foundation had a paid membership of 600 persons who came from all walks of life. An eight month season of eight or nine public lectures presented analysts from around the world and these talks were regularly attended by 300-400 members and non-members alike in an easily accessible public auditorium. In addition, numerous and regular seminars were also available.At present, there are about 75 paid members, mostly academics (very pleasant and agreeable people), but the public lectures, given by local analysts for the most part, occur only about two or three times a season and are held in small lecture rooms barely attracting 75-80 people at most. In addition, a couple of long-established Jung Foundations in other cities had to shut down for a lack of interest in recent years.While I know that there are various flourishing groups related to the study of Jung's ideas, I don't believe that this is a growing trend in general, especially when it comes to moving further into society as opposed to a kind of "let's stick with the 1%" approach.This is likely due in part to what I would call a fairly frequent tendency to a kind of isolationism among Jungians in general, however friendly they might be. And this situation is added to by the sometimes "florid" and impractical language related to Jungian ideas that can appear in a book like this one.So again to quote the blurb, the book "offers the seasoned dream worker as well as the novice great insight into the meaning of the dream and its amplification", but I personally would not recommend this book to someone who wants to start learning about approaching dreams from a Jungian standpoint.Better books for this task include analyst Robert Johnson's venerable "Inner Work" and Dr. Jung's opening chapter of "Man and His Symbols". "Jungian Dream Analysis" by James Hall is also very valuable along with various other books by Mary Ann Mattoon, Marion Rauscher Gallbach, Donald Broadribb, Edward C. Whitmont and others.To sum up, in reading "The Dream and its Amplification", the "seasoned dream worker" in my opinion would likely have a mixed experience, probably enjoying, for example, "Coal or Gold? The Symbolic Understanding of Alpine Legends" while perhaps not being as keen on, for instance, "Sophia's Dreaming Body".
Trustpilot
1 day ago
1 month ago