Riley's 12 Inch Beef Collagen Sticks for Dogs, Collagen Chews for Dogs, Bully Stick & Rawhide Alternative, Long Lasting, No Raw Hide Chews, Single Ingredient Dog Treat - 5 ct

We have big dogs and tiny dogs and they all love them. There is no mess, not broken pieces. Their teeth are not bleeding are harmed like with other harder chews and they keep them occupied and busy. My little dogs make them last longer and they tend to come back to them over time while the larger dogs devour them in one sitting.

These chew sticks last quite a long time. George loves them and guards them as if his life depended on them.

Very healthy teeth cleaning treat.

These are loved by my two dachshunds, and kept occupied for hours.

Quality product. My mastiff loves them

At first I was glad to have found a cheaper alternative to pizzle sticks for my dog to clean her teeth. I didn't get suspicious about how natural this stuff is until I noticed the big stains it leaves on my carpets. So I looked into how this may be manufactured, since it definitely seems to have some sort of dye to it.So I looked into what beef chorion is. The package doesn't specify where or how they source it. I can be sources from bones as well as a skin layer, which is usually a left over from other processes, the same as raw hide. It doesn't seem like it can be obtained as a sheet or layer, as the product makes it seem. It seems to be meant to look like a rolled sheet. It also doesn't seem that chorion would have much color to it.The brownish stains make me believe this is made with a dye and something to make the chorion adhere in order to become a sheet that can be rolled.The dog is also not too much into it. She'll eventually chew it but not as eagerly as pizzle.Overall the secretive nature of the product and the mess it makes, plus the dog not being as into it is making me choose to spend more on pizzle again and not get a "beef chorion " product again. At least with pizzle I can identify what it is and the process is pretty clear too

We have an Anatolian Shepherd/Hound mix and have been buying him bully sticks for a while as he loves them. Recently, two different brands I was purchasing, were either out of stock or kept raising their prices. I started looking into other brands and came across these. They are listed as collagen sticks but pretty much are the same thing. Best part is they were much cheaper.I ordered, opened the bag upon arrival, and yep! These smell the same. Absolutely awful. Our dog thinks they smell divine however. After carefully removing one from the bag so as not to have the scent all over my hands, I gave him one and he happily took it into the other room and got into his dog bed. I washed my hands (seriously, the smell really is gross) as he chomped away. He's not a small dog by any means. Clocking in at around 80-85 pounds, he's a fairly big boy. I won't say these are supremely long lasting, but he wasn't quick to finish it either. I had more than enough time to get some dog free things done around the house while he ignored me in favor of his treat.They arrived packaged well and as stated above, last long enough. He didn't have any stomach upset or sensitivities with them. Given the lower price in comparison to other brands, I have already ordered these several more times and if all stays the same, will continue to do so.

Alright valueDon't last long enoughDogs chew through them Easy!