Fat and The Moon - All Natural/Organic Eye Coal (Black.25 oz)

Highly pigmented, doesn't smear or break me out, does transfer a bit (I have very hooded eyes) but is easy to clean up, does well enough in the waterline, a little goes a long way actually and I'm still learning to only pick up what I actually need since I use this for eyes and brows (mostly brows), has decent hold, this product is a bit shiny but I just lightly pat what's left of my setting powder over it and I'm good all day, does seem to have stained my white synthetic brush a bit gray after washing it off after a week of use, plays well over eyebrow pencil and under eyebrow powder/ eye shadow. Haven't tried it as mascara, but I've heard it works for that but isn't super dramatic like I like, so maybe one day if I ever have a clean spooly. I'm looking forward to trying the rest of the line.

Bought this on April 2019 and use it a few times until today, it smells weird even fresh new and the feel is so rough, so dry that I can’t take any product to put on mi eyes... waste of money :(

I always used Bare Minerals powdered liner... but I ended up with black dust in my cheeks, which smeared, got on clothes, ruined everything, and never washed off completely. I switched to a pencil, which made my lids break out in a rash. This product does well, has healthful ingredients, goes on easily, and washes off easily. My only drawback-- I have to make sure not to moisturize the area around my eyes or the liner runs.

Love this stuff. I’ve been trying to switch to more natural products, and have been using this an an eyeliner. It def smudges a bit more and fades a little more than the liner I used to wear, but I expected that. Overall, I’m a fan.

I hoped this would be good for using as black eyeliner. I literally could not get it to apply, stick in any kind of reasonable manner. It's got a consistency like wax, and just balls up for the most part. I really feel like I'm missing something? I tried different brushes, using moisture, not using moisture on the brush, and even a Q-tip just to scoop it out and press it on. No go. This stuff would not go on my eyelids, no way, no how. Now maybe as theatrical style eye makeup if that's what you want, you could glob it on..? I don't know.

Love this, not to thick, perfect for all day or night wear!

The color barely showed. I am dissapointed as I had high hopes for this. Will continue to search for another all natural eyeliner.

Love. It smudges a bit but the color is beautiful and it feels light on the skin.