Smart Adventure Gear Hook & Go 100% Waterproof Roof Top Cargo Carrier Roof Bag, 5 Year Warranty, 23 Cubic Feet

It had water in bag. I ready some other reviews that said the same so I was prepared and put all our gear in garbage bags. It worked great other than water getting in.

We drove from New York to Texas with this on top of our SUV. It didn’t budge! It rained several times and our belongings were completely dry. It is a great product!

Way great better than the cheap target one I got