Mally BeautyEvercolor Starlight Waterproof Eyeliner - Caribbean Sea - Smudge-Proof, Longwear, Creamy Gel - Sharpenable Eyeliner

This is the BEST eyeliner I have ever had! It was originally given to me as a gift. Since then I have reordered this Mally stick. It has staying power and the color does not fade or easily come off! It is easy to apply and is forgiving of mistakes.

Wonderful product mud resistant color qualities is amazing. Texture is out of this world. Does not irritate my skin stays on very well does not smudge.

This eyeliner glides on smooth as silk without barely applying pressure. Best eyeliner I have ever used and I've been wearing eyeliner since 1972. Great value for the price as well. Thank you Mally!!!

I love this stuff. It's bullet-proof (lasts all day).

I am always searching for a good dark eyeliner that will stay put throughout the day. I'm reasonable to think that I may need to reapply once or twice a day, but need something that won't give me racoon eyes soon after application. I stare at a computer screen all day and my eyes become watery and tired easily.I am happy to say this eyeliner has hit the mark. It is very smooth and applies dark. I have been wearing it for a few days and it stays put. No smudging. No racoon eyes. I apply to the lower eye/waterline area. It works great there. I took a nap and woke up to find the eyeliner still in place with just a little smudging into the inner corner of the eye.I tried it on the top line (above the lashes) and sadly it did not stay put. It smudges in the inner corner and also the outer corner leaving me with bloops of black "eye buggers".I would definitely recommend this eyeliner. Mally is the bomb! I will definitely be trying more of her collection.

The last time i bought i had this pencil in purple packaging. The formula was great. This time i had it in black packaging. It doesnt feel good as the purple packaging. I feel like this is an old packaging i got bc i also use to got the black packaging from a beauty subscription. Paying $30 for something that its not really the same os disappointed

This is my absolute favorite brand and color! Goes on smoothly and stays put.

I love the texture, but it just falls off your face. That makes it easy to remove but at the same time after a couple of hours he will have raccoon eyes.