WELL PEOPLE - Fresh Lines Eye Pencil | Clean, Non-Toxic Beauty (Black)

It glides on and does not tug at sensitive eye areas. Wipes off easily with baby oil or eye makeup remover.

does not make my eyes water, it is amazing!

I like that this product is natural but it makes my eyes water a short while after applying.

I still am giving this product a 3 star rating even though I can't use it, because I love that W3LL PEOPLE spent time to source naturally. Unfortunately it smudges like crazy on me, within a few minutes of putting it on, I looked like a total Panda. I have combination skin, and used it on my upper eyelid and lower lash line. I am pretty disappointed that I can't use it. But if smudging has never been an issue for you, I think you could still try it out. It's reasonably priced and prior to it smudging, the application was good, smooth and easy to use.

LOVE this. I recently ordered several different brands of non-toxic make up (Au Naturale, Mineral Hygienics, Vapor, 100% Pure) and this little baby is by far the most impressive. I do a smokey eye usually, and I have yet to find a non-toxic black eye shadow. So I use this by putting on a thick line of it and smudging it out until it blends into a nice ombre smokey eye. If you have a good base (eye shadow primer or some sort of powder) below it, then it will stay all day without creasing.

I love this company and use their lipsticks all the time so wanted to try the eye liner as hopefully I can switch from Lancôme in order to lessen chemicals in my makeup. The eyeliner goes on very easily and I love that but it does smudge. My eyes tear easily so there is black under the eye smudged up at the end of the day so not loving that aspect!

Does not smudge under the eye.

Love the way it went on, stayed on for hours, no smudging. First day trying it and my eyes like it.

Love the eyeliner - very smooth and gentle on skin

Good product. Dark black colour. Does not smudge. It's costly as it's imported from the US. The reason that I got it is that W3ll People is listed among the safe products on the EWG website. I'll buy it again though it's not cheap.