Mellow Cosmetics Gel Lip Pencil - Matte Liner for Women - Long-Lasting & No Bleeding - Organic, Natural, Vegan, Cruelty-Free - Paraben-Free Makeup - Rose - Rose

Colors were a little tricky but I got the Rose and it's very natural, which is what I wanted. The pencil is a bit soft but goes on smoothly, it's also a very concentrated color (meaning, even though it's a natural color, I can still line the lips outside without it looking sheer and showing the edges of my lips - which has been an issue with other brands' pencils of natural-looking colors). I tried many other brands, but this is the one for me, and will buy more!

Color was not a shown on line

While I really liked the color and the smooth texture, the pencil did not work. In other words, the winding mechanism did not work. So I was only able to use the color on my lips for about three days before it was too low. Will not order again. Sad Day!

i love the color, but the tip fell off after only 1 use

Mellow lip pencils are the hidden gem of makeup. Best lip pencil out there. Creamy, doesn’t dry your lips, andchas staying power. I won’t use any other andcthey are affordable

Pencil arrived with broken tip and mechanical end will not bring more of color up to use.

The product goes on nicely and stays on pretty well. I’m just a little bummed that the “rose” color looks much more orange in person.

I love this liner! I’ve searched and searched for a non-toxic “organic” liner that actually stays on and has good pigmentation...well, here it is! I bought the Maya. Love it, but may be too dark for every day use for me. Went back and ordered lighter colors: Ava and Aria.