From School Library Journal Grade 4 Up?A stunningly illustrated, well-written retelling of one of Mozart's most beloved works. This operatic fairy tale is related in an elegant, clear tone in 15 scenes; most have a single page of text and one facing full-page painting. This technique breaks the rather complicated story into easy-to-follow pieces. Malone's soft oil paintings are full of light; stylized but warm, they precisely catch the flavor of Mozart's vision. Story and pictures are lovely, fresh, and rich, but it is the enclosed CD with 16 selections coded to each page of the book that make this a unique and appealing offering. This reading-plus-listening package is almost as good as being in the audience. Libraries may encounter problems circulating a book with a CD tucked in the back, but this a special item and it deserves a place on the music shelves of most libraries. A beautiful treat for the eyes, the ears, and the imagination.?Beth Tegart, Oneida City Schools, NYCopyright 1998 Reed Business Information, Inc. Read more From Kirkus Reviews This retelling of Mozart's wonderful opera works particularly well for two reasons. First is the eye-catching appeal of Malone's illustrations, with their gorgeous theater-set qualities, fresco naturalness, and zesty characterizations. The second is that Gatti keeps tempo of the opera in her text, with pleasingly swift scene changes and quick character portraits. She neither simplifies the story, nor bevels its edges: Papageno might be there for light relief, Tamino and Pamina feel destined for one another despite their miscues, but good and evil often wear their opposite qualities, and the mother, disquietingly, is still the most evil of all; consider the scene outside the temple walls (Pamina: ``Oh, Mother, I don't know what to do! Please protect me.'' Queen of the Night: ``Protect you?''). An audio CD is included (with musical cues in the book); if everything pales before the music, readers will still sense how the opera's magic worked on Gatti and Malone, and gain an entry to the magic themselves. (Picture book. 7-11) -- Copyright ©1997, Kirkus Associates, LP. All rights reserved. Read more See all Editorial Reviews
S**E
My 2-1/2 year old daughter is obsessed
I bought this because we were going to see a local abbreviated production. Now, my daughter wants us to read it to her all the time. And she wants the CD playing in the background as we read. She is very happy that Papagena wears pink. She is very concerned about the padlock on Papageno's mouth. She has cast the opera from the beautiful illustrations. The first lady is Mommy, the other ladies are her sitter and her sitter's mother (?). Her brother Will is the serpent, "but it is just a costume." "Mommy kills 'ill" is a frequent refrain (wishful thinking? Nah, she dotes on her brother. She is just type-casting. That is why I, her father, is Prince Tamino. She knows many of the details of the story, even though we often selectively edit the text when we read it to her.My only quibbles, as someone who has performed, directed and conducted this opera many times, are the odd deviations from the libretto. Some plot points are muddled and some characters are misinterpreted. I find myself telling the story as written by Schikaneder and Mozart more often than not, which is extra work. Also, some of the musical selections are odd. I would have picked numbers that move the plot such as the quintet of the "bad guys" in the finale rather than arias that stop the show, such as Sarastro's snoozer.
W**E
Wonderful Adjunct to the Music
This retelling is child friendly as well as a nice overview of the opera's plot for any age of reader. It is best as a read aloud - in smallish doses - to children younger than fourth grade due to the word density. I send this book home frequently when my piano students play excerpts from The Magic Flute. The artwork is bright, and the CD gives the students an idea of the original work. I recommend reading the book and then viewing some scenes on YouTube.
J**R
Make sure you're getting the right version!
I just wanted to warn people thinking of getting this book -- make sure you're getting the one you want! The editorial review for the children's version of "The Magic Flute" refers in part to a Black Dog Opera version -- *that's* the one with the libretto and two CDs. The children's version (retold by Anne Gatti) has only one CD of selections from the opera, and no libretto, just a retelling of the story. I bought the children's version by mistake, based on the editorial review and the customer reviews (some of which also claim that 2 CDs are included), but it turns out these do not refer at all to the children's version.That said, if you're just looking for something for your kids, definitely go for the children's version (ASIN 0811810038). The illustrations are cute, and the text is written to follow along with the CD selections... fine for the age range they indicate. If, however, you want the full libretto with translations, and the full opera on CD, make sure you get the "Black Dog" version which is referenced as "hardcover edition" on the kid's version page. (Hope that makes sense!)
A**A
BUY IT WITH THE DVD AS A PRESENT TO CHILDREN (OF ALL AGES)
I did not buy this for myself, but for my seven year old grand nephew, together the the abridged Met Magic Flute. His father, my nephew, has reported the go together like hand and glove. I trust his judgement, so I am recommending the combo to anyone who wants to introduce children to the magic of opera.
L**L
Great for grades 2-6
It's got great pictures and the CD has tracks that go along with each page. I don't recommend it for any students younger than 2nd grade. It's very "wordy."
K**R
Perfect introduction to Opera--3-7 year olds
This is sheer genius! Put the opera in CD form, and attach a nice picture book for children, and you have a perfect classic. I hope more books like this are on the way. This is a perfect introduction to a masterwork of opera.I confess that "The Magic Flute" is my favorite opera. It retells the ancient Freemason legends in opera and dramatic form, so you know that the story is rather primeval and sacred. I am glad, therefore, to see that someone has transposed the story for children. The book and the legend hold up well against "The Odyssey," Shakespeare, and Harry Potter, and the story has an incredible soundtrack to boot.After all, we are really focused on the mysterious music and the incredible love story of Tamino and Pamina, and the trials that keep these two apart. The more I read and ponder the story, and ultimately its esoteric message, the more I love this story.The CD is perfect and without hiss or crackle. The book is geared for a 3-7 year old, and doesn't do the story justice. However, it is a great introduction to this opera.
E**A
Mozart's The Magic Flute
This was a wonderful story well written for a young audience. We bought it for our six-year-old son who began studying violin a year ago, and this was his one-year anniversary present. Mozart's Eine Kleine Nacht Musik was his inspiration to learn the violin, and he has since taken interest in other Mozart music. The illustrations are also very beautiful.
S**M
It's a great book.
I got The Magic Flute for Christmas. My teacher is almost finished reading it to the class. We also listen to the CD after she reads the part to it. Some people in my class don't know if they like it a lot or not. Most of them love it. Ruth Stuart, 2nd grade
Trustpilot
2 months ago
5 days ago