Kirkland Signature WalkersPremium Shortbread Selection Gift Tin, 4.6 Pound, Packaging May Vary

Classic product. Classy packaging with large metal tin box.

I have ordered these last year and twice this year. Many of the round cookies are always broken; the others are not. The finger cookies have far more sugar than the other two variety of cookies. The round cookies are far more broken and I am unsure as to why. A few of the triangle cookies have cracked; none the less they are very tasty. One review wrote that the taste with Kirkland is different than the ones direct from Scotland and this is true. The finger cookies are the most changed; and the Kirkland brand is better and far more sugar is involved! These are not broken, on the several times I've ordered them thru this site. I will continue to order these cookies; I'm afraid I am too greedy as the last bunch I ordered I gave at least half a way; due to my weight gain of eating the last entire batch of Kirkland shortbread cookies from Walkers! I will probably order them again at Christmas and eat some and give the rest away. Hopefully I will loose the ten pounds I've gained since ordering the last batch! They are so good and my will power is low. I'm laughing; I've no history of diabetes and had lost a great deal of weight last year, actually was quite thin. So I need to lose ten to 12 pounds so I can get into my small clothes again and will do so by NOT ordering again until Christmas and I will give many away. They will make great Christmas present to friends, colleagues.

Excellent product, accurate product description and prompt shipment.

The cookies were all broken but I have it on good authority that the calories leak out when the cookies break so these were actually lowere in calories than normal.

delicious

This is a huge tin of cookies and I think it is a really good price for what you get. Inside you get 12 individually wrapped packages of cookies, so I think they will stay fresh for a long time. I was a little disappointed by the appearance of the cookies, however. They are not as pretty or detailed as the last, smaller box of cookies that I had. That box had four different shapes; triangle, oval, round and fingers. They all had nice holes poked in them and except for the fingers, scroll type edges, very attractive. This box contained the triangles, round and fingers. Probably as many round ones as the other 2 shapes combined. Also about half of the fingers appear to maybe be square, having not been cut in half. That makes for a pretty large cookie and harder to ration if you only want to eat one.. I prefer them smaller. I also like to dunk them in my coffee if I am eating them in the morning and they would be too big to dunk. The triangles are very similar in appearance to the ones in the other box. The round ones are just plain round cookies, no holes and no scrolls. The fingers have the fork holes, but just not as pretty as the ones from the other box. Also, a fair amount of the round ones arrived broken in half. Of course that doesn't affect their taste and they are delicious, just like my first box-- light, delicate, buttery and fresh. In retrospect, I got exactly what was pictured on the tin, but since they aren't as pretty as the other Walker's shortbread cookies that I had and half of the fingers are really squares, I am only giving this 4 stars.

I usually am forced to wait till holidays to get these cookies at a big box store (S$#MS)... this year available only thru mail order.... Amazon to the rescue!... I got over 4 POUNDS of these amazing cookies...delivered right to my door. Tin looks perfect (gosh, it is BIG)... think I'm all set till next year!

Tin was in a box with no packing. Four layers of cookies all but the top layer were broken, crushed, top layer was in fair shape because they are the smaller rectangular cookies that are packaged tighter. We love these cookies a shame not much you can do with crushed cookies.